Search by Map
Canada keyboard_arrow_right
Manitoba keyboard_arrow_right
Winnipeg keyboard_arrow_right
Bed Bug Meter
0 Yes Votes
2 No Votes
Does this property have bed bugs?
to cast your vote or to certify as bed bug free.
Last No Vote: February 22, 2018
Cockroach Meter
0 Yes Votes
2 No Votes
Does this property have cockroaches?
to cast your vote or to certify as cockroach free.
Last No Vote: February 22, 2018
Who Lives Here?
 Students
 Singles
 Couples
 Families
 Seniors
6 total submissions.

Aetna Manor

3.1 Star Rating
566 McMillan Ave, Winnipeg Manitoba
Subscribe
It's important to us that all of our details are up to date! Please provide us with as much information as you can:
Property Name:
Managed by:
Management Website:
Type of Property (apartment, duplex, etc.):
Your Email Address:
Overall Rating based on 5 Reviews
3.1
3.1 Star Rating

Management
2.4 Star Rating
Heating
2.7 Star Rating
Cooling
1 Star Rating
Maintenance
1.7 Star Rating
Laundry
2.3 Star Rating
Parking
1 Star Rating
Cleanliness
3.8 Star Rating
Storage
4 Star Rating
Neighbourhood
4.4 Star Rating
Quietness
4 Star Rating
Safety
3 Star Rating
Hot Water
4.3 Star Rating
Need affordable tenant insurance? Check out our deal with Nuera Insurance!
February 22, 2018
2.9
2.9 Star Rating

Management
2 Star Rating
Heating
2 Star Rating
Cooling
1 Star Rating
Maintenance
1 Star Rating
Laundry
3 Star Rating
Parking
1 Star Rating
Cleanliness
4 Star Rating
Storage
4 Star Rating
Neighbourhood
5 Star Rating
Quietness
4 Star Rating
Safety
4 Star Rating
Hot Water
4 Star Rating
Reviewer says...
Pretty decent for price and area. Previous caretakers were not very helpful and didn't really have a clue. New caretakers are great, helpful, pro-active, and regularly clean. I would move back into this apartment if my spouse didn't drag me closer to work.

Smith Agency is like an old aging, grumpy, and marginally helpful management group, if you are extra nice to them.

Maintenance response to in-suite issues is horrible and better off hiring your own handy-person if you are not opposed to paying out of your own pocket. I suspect that is due to communication between Smith Agency and the dubious personnel they hire for maintenance.

No issues with noise personally. Perhaps one grumpy, overly sensitive tenant but hey, every apartment has one of those.

You will need your own A/C in the summer and will need to crack open your windows in the winter frequently especially if you use your oven for cooking.

Two in-suite laundry washers and driers. Card operated and re-loadable. Can't complain.

Ample storage space for typical needs. Might want to take some extra measurements if you have camping/outdoor/sports obsessions.

Safety is alright. A few shady characters frequently take shortcuts through the side-path between the fence and the apartment though so make sure your windows are locked if you are in one of the garden-suites. Only a few instances of suspicious activity; where once someone left a crowbar near a window and dumped a bunch of empty beer cans near a window. Not a problem if you wedge a piece of wood between the sliding part of your window if you want extra protection. But hey, that's the nature of being close to the village.

Parking is a several-month to 1 year wait list. Quite unfortunate for those poor souls who need to plug in their vehicles for the winter or move them during snow plowing.

Hot water is nice and toasty. A few times a year it turns brown due to City Of Winnipeg shenanigans but it's usually corrected within half a day.
smoking_rooms No Smoking Allowed
pets No Pets Allowed
This review is solely the opinion of the reviewer and not of RentItOrNot.
Report
Review helpful? 1


November 05, 2017
2.7
2.7 Star Rating

Management
2 Star Rating
Heating
3 Star Rating
Parking
1 Star Rating
Maintenance
2 Star Rating
Laundry
1 Star Rating
Neighbourhood
5 Star Rating
Cleanliness
3 Star Rating
Safety
3 Star Rating
Hot Water
5 Star Rating
Quietness
4 Star Rating
Cooling
1 Star Rating
Reviewer says...
Be careful. It's an old building and the apartments are not good quality. However, be extra careful when renting a room from someone in the building as they have a tenant involved in scamming students and the revenue agency. I have reported it to the Smith Agency but nothing was done.

Also, it's stupid hot in summer and there's no A/C.
smoking_rooms No Smoking Allowed
pets No Pets Allowed
This review is solely the opinion of the reviewer and not of RentItOrNot.
Report
Review helpful?

December 06, 2016
3.1
3.1 Star Rating

Management
1 Star Rating
Heating
3 Star Rating
Parking
1 Star Rating
Maintenance
2 Star Rating
Laundry
3 Star Rating
Neighbourhood
4 Star Rating
Cleanliness
4 Star Rating
Storage
4 Star Rating
Hot Water
4 Star Rating
Quietness
4 Star Rating
Safety
4 Star Rating
Reviewer says...
Good size/spacious suites, rental rates are good, new caretakers are friendly and responsive (previous couple who just left near the end of 2016 was disorganized and in over their heads). I am rating management, maintenance, and parking low because the Smith Agency has been terrible to deal with on many levels. 2 other people I know who rented with them have left and looked elsewhere. 15 month work orders for plumbing and simple repairs that haven't been filled, missing documents, and still no parking spot after a year.
This review is solely the opinion of the reviewer and not of RentItOrNot.
Report
Review helpful?

March 01, 2013
2.8
2.8 Star Rating

Management
2 Star Rating
Quietness
5 Star Rating
Neighbourhood
3 Star Rating
Cleanliness
3 Star Rating
Safety
1 Star Rating
Reviewer says...
This place smells like boiled cabbage.

[This review has been modified from its original submission to comply with our terms of use guidelines. However, the opinion expressed in this review has not been altered.]
Portions of this review have been removed to comply with our Terms. It remains solely the opinion of the reviewer and not of RentItOrNot.
Report
Review helpful?

August 27, 2012
4.2
4.2 Star Rating

Management
5 Star Rating
Quietness
3 Star Rating
Neighbourhood
5 Star Rating
Cleanliness
5 Star Rating
Safety
3 Star Rating
This review is solely the opinion of the reviewer and not of RentItOrNot.
Report
Review helpful?